NUO AI logo NUO AI
Book a call Add app — Free
Comparison · Updated 3 November 2026

Best pick your gift apps for Shopify, compared

Not every gift-with-purchase app lets the shopper choose — many only auto-add one fixed gift. These five specifically support a gift-picker mode, and their free tiers are capped in four different units — live rules, attributed revenue, lifetime orders, and monthly orders. Every figure below was read from that app’s own Shopify App Store listing on the same day and quoted verbatim.

The short answer

EG Auto Add to Cart has the highest review count of the dedicated gift-picker apps at 1,156, but its free tier caps at a single live gift rule. TL Free Gifts ties its free plan to $1,000 of monthly revenue on Basic stores. BOGOS gives a 30-lifetime-order allowance that functions as a trial. Fokkio resets monthly at 10 orders. NUO AI — our own app, disclosed below — states no cap on its gift-picker widget, with a much shorter review history than the other four.

What ends each free plan

All five apps here let the shopper pick from an approved set of gifts rather than receiving one fixed item. The picker UI is close to interchangeable; the cap is what differs. Ratings and review counts are as shown on the Shopify App Store on 3 November 2026.

AppRatingFree planCap unitWhat it costs next
NUO AI
our app		5.0 · thin review historyGift-picker widget, no stated cap—No paid tier
EG Auto Add to Cart
506		5.0 · 1,156“1 live gift rule”Concurrent rules$14.99/mo Standard (3 rules)
TL Free Gifts BOGO & Upsell
Tek Labs		5.0 · 581“$1,000 monthly revenue for Shopify Basic stores”Attributed revenue, store-plan dependentScales with Shopify plan, 7-day trial on higher tiers
BOGOS
BOGOS		5.0 · 4,643“30 free orders lifetime by BOGOS”Lifetime orders$29.99/mo Basic (300 orders)
Fokkio
Fokkio		4.8 · 85“Up to 10 orders per month” + 3 promotionsOrders, resets monthly$4.99/mo Basic (50 orders)

Source for every row: the app’s own Shopify App Store pricing section, read 3 November 2026. The App Store showed pricing in INR for this session; USD figures above for EG Auto Add to Cart are converted at the page’s own stated rate and rounded — confirm the exact figure on the listing before installing. TL's paid-tier price is shown only after selecting a Shopify plan on the listing and was not independently converted here.

The cap unit decides which app survives at your volume, not the feature list. “1 live gift rule” and “$1,000 of revenue” are not comparable, and neither is comparable to “30 lifetime orders” or “10 orders a month.” A store running one picker offer stays free on EG indefinitely; a store wanting two different picker offers at once needs EG's $14.99 tier on day one regardless of volume.

Who wrote this, and the bias you should assume

This comparison is published by NUO AI, and NUO AI is one of the five apps in it. That is a real conflict of interest and no amount of methodology removes it.

What we did to keep it usable anyway: every competitor’s pricing and rating was read from its own Shopify App Store listing on 3 November 2026 rather than copied from another roundup; each entry below names something that app does better than NUO AI; and NUO AI’s own entry states its shorter review history rather than burying it.

If you would rather not take a vendor’s word for a vendor comparison, the useful part of this page is the cap-unit table above — every figure in it is checkable against a public listing in under a minute.

The five apps

NUO AI — the only uncapped gift-picker free tier here, and the newest app here

Our app 5.0 · thin review history · NUO AI, Manhattan NY

Start with the caveat. Every other app on this page has between 85 and 4,643 App Store reviews. NUO AI has far fewer. If track record is your selection criterion, this is the wrong app on this page and one of the others is the right one.

What it offers in exchange is a gift-picker widget — shoppers choose from an approved set once they qualify — with no stated cap on rules, revenue, or orders, bundled with the rest of NUO AI's offer types at $0 and no paid tier to graduate into.

  • Free planGift-picker widget included, no stated rule, revenue or order cap
  • Paid tierNone
  • Best forStores running more than one picker offer at once, where competitors' rule caps start charging immediately
  • Weakest atTrack record — a short App Store history against competitors with hundreds to thousands of reviews

Full breakdown of how pick-your-gift works in NUO AI · Shopify App Store listing

EG Auto Add to Cart — the most-reviewed dedicated picker app, capped by rule count

5.0 · 1,156 reviews · 506

EG Auto Add to Cart holds the #1 spot on the Shopify App Store for auto-add-to-cart apps, and its gift-picker mode opens a popup so shoppers choose their own free gift rather than receiving one fixed item. Triggers include cart subtotal, specific product, collection, or customer tag.

The free tier caps at one rule, not one order count. “1 live gift rule” means a single picker offer running at a time. A store wanting a different picker offer for a second collection or segment needs the $14.99/mo Standard tier for 3 rules.

  • Free plan“1 live gift rule”, popup or auto-add choice, customer-tag targeting
  • Next tier$14.99/mo Standard (3 rules) · $29.99/mo Unlimited · $49.99/mo Enterprise (Shopify Plus)
  • Beats NUO AI at1,156 reviews, the #1 category ranking, and customer-tag-based targeting

Shopify App Store listing

TL Free Gifts BOGO & Upsell — the free tier scales with revenue, not a hard rule limit

5.0 · 581 reviews · Tek Labs

TL lets shoppers automatically receive a gift or choose their own, alongside BOGO, Buy X Get Y, classic bundles, volume discounts and frequently-bought-together — a wider feature set than most dedicated picker apps, bundled with cart-progress-bar and checkout widgets.

The cap is tied to revenue, and only for Basic-plan stores. The free tier states “$1,000 monthly revenue for Shopify Basic stores” — higher Shopify plans may see a different figure, and the listing shows paid-tier pricing only after a store plan is selected, so it isn't a single fixed number to quote.

  • Free plan“$1,000 monthly revenue for Shopify Basic stores” · gift picker, BOGO, bundles, volume discounts
  • Next tierScales with Shopify plan tier · 7-day free trial on paid plans
  • Beats NUO AI at581 reviews, and a wider bundled feature set (bundles, volume discounts, FBT) alongside the gift picker

Shopify App Store listing

BOGOS — the deepest promotional mechanics, the tightest free tier

5.0 · 4,643 reviews · BOGOS

BOGOS supports a gift-picker popup alongside its wider BOGO, bundle and mix-and-match mechanics, and auto-add still handles delivery once the shopper picks. It is the most established app in this comparison by review count, with POS and headless support.

The free tier is not really an ongoing plan. “30 free orders lifetime by BOGOS” is spent once, and the first paid tier runs $29.99/month. Merchants who want BOGOS' bundle depth alongside the gift picker should budget for it.

  • Free plan“30 free orders lifetime by BOGOS” — gift picker, BOGO/BXGY, bundles, mix and match
  • Next tier$29.99/mo Basic (300 orders) · $49.99/mo Grow (600) · $109.99/mo Plus (2,000)
  • Beats NUO AI at4,643 reviews, POS/headless support, and bundle depth beyond the gift picker

Shopify App Store listing

Fokkio — a monthly-resetting cap for low-volume picker offers

4.8 · 85 reviews · Fokkio

Fokkio's gift-picker mode lets the shopper choose in the cart, with the same triggers as its fixed-GWP mode (cart total, product, collection, customer tag) and a secret-link option for influencer or VIP-only picker offers.

The cap resets every month rather than draining a lifetime pool. “Up to 10 orders per month” plus 3 promotions is narrow, but it never permanently runs out the way a lifetime allowance does — useful for a store testing a picker offer in short, repeated bursts.

  • Free plan“Up to 10 orders per month” · 3 promotions · gift-picker and secret-link VIP mode
  • Next tier$4.99/mo Basic (50 orders) · $9.99/mo Professional (500) · $19.99/mo Unlimited
  • Beats NUO AI atSecret-link VIP offers, and the lowest paid entry price in this comparison

Shopify App Store listing

How to pick, in one question

Decide how many simultaneous picker offers you need, and at what order volume, before comparing feature lists.

Your situationWhat the caps doWhere to look first
One picker offer, low volumeNearly every free tier survivesEG Auto Add to Cart or Fokkio
Multiple picker offers at onceEG's rule cap bites immediatelyTL (revenue-based) or NUO AI (no cap)
Want bundles/volume discounts alongside the pickerDedicated picker apps don't bundle thisTL or BOGOS
Growing past a Basic-plan revenue capTL's free tier is plan-dependentRe-check TL's listing at your Shopify plan, or NUO AI for no cap
You do not want a cap to think aboutOnly one option here has noneNUO AI — accepting the shorter track record

What this comparison does not tell you

Three things it deliberately does not claim, because the evidence for them does not exist:

It does not measure picker-vs-fixed conversion lift. No controlled test comparing a picker offer against a fixed gift on identical traffic was found publicly. The pattern — choice removes the “I don't want that” objection — is well reasoned, not independently verified at a specific percentage.

It does not verify picker UI quality side by side. All five apps show the picker as a popup or in-cart widget; actual look, load time and theme compatibility were not tested on a live store for this comparison.

Pricing goes stale, and currency display is regional. Everything here was read on 3 November 2026. The Shopify App Store showed INR pricing for this session for EG Auto Add to Cart; the USD figure is converted at the page's own stated rate and rounded. TL's paid pricing depends on the store's Shopify plan and was not independently priced. Confirm exact figures on each listing before installing.

Frequently asked questions

What is a pick-your-gift app?

A pick-your-gift app lets a shopper choose their own free gift from an approved set once they qualify, instead of receiving one fixed gift automatically. It's a variant of gift with purchase (GWP) — the mechanic is the same spend or quantity trigger, but the shopper gets a choice rather than a single predetermined item.

Which Shopify apps actually support shopper-chosen gifts, not just fixed GWP?

As of 3 November 2026, five widely used apps support a gift-picker mode where the shopper chooses: NUO AI, BOGOS, EG Auto Add to Cart, TL Free Gifts BOGO & Upsell, and Fokkio. Not every GWP app offers this — some only support one fixed gift per rule, so confirm the picker specifically before installing if shopper choice is the point.

What actually ends a free pick-your-gift app plan?

Four different units. EG Auto Add to Cart caps at 1 live gift rule. TL caps at $1,000 of monthly revenue on Shopify Basic stores. BOGOS gives 30 lifetime orders, spent once. Fokkio allows 10 orders a month, resetting monthly. NUO AI states no cap on any of these.

Does picking your own gift convert better than a fixed gift?

Letting a shopper choose removes the single most common objection to fixed GWP — "I don't want that specific item" — so acceptance rates are generally reported higher for picker-style offers across this category. No independent, controlled study comparing fixed vs. picker GWP head-to-head on identical traffic exists publicly, so treat this as a well-reasoned pattern, not a verified percentage.

Is EG Auto Add to Cart's free plan enough for an ongoing picker offer?

Only if you run exactly one gift rule. The free plan caps at "1 live gift rule," which is enough to run a single threshold with a choice of gifts, but not enough to run different picker offers for different collections or customer segments at the same time.

Why does NUO AI appear in its own comparison?

Because leaving it out would be its own kind of bias. NUO AI publishes this comparison and is one of the five apps in it. Every competitor's pricing and feature claim below was read from its own Shopify App Store listing on 3 November 2026, each entry names something that app does better than NUO AI, and NUO AI's shorter review history is stated rather than hidden.

How many App Store reviews does NUO AI have compared to these apps?

Far fewer. The other four apps on this page range from 85 to 4,643 reviews as of 3 November 2026. If track record matters more to you than cap flexibility, weigh that heavily — this page does not argue otherwise.

Can I limit which gifts a shopper can pick from?

Yes, across every app in this comparison. You set the approved gift set (typically 2 to 4 products) and the trigger that unlocks it; the shopper only ever sees and picks from the products you approved, not your full catalog.

No rule cap to plan around.

If a 1-rule limit or a revenue cap is what's putting you off, NUO AI has none — and a shorter track record, which you should weigh honestly against the alternatives on this page.

Add app on Shopify — Free